A few years back I dated a girl who loved Diamonds. I drove by a few times and didn’t like the crowd I saw. It was a mix of college frat boys and guys with wife beaters pretending to be “hard”. I never once went with my ex. To be honest, I never had one desire to go there. Funny since I used to live 1 mile away.
Last week a couple of my lady friends from work wanted to go. I really didn’t want to go. At the same time, they are my friends and I wanted to hangout. So I ended up going. I actually ended up having a great time. Don’t get me wrong. Most of my great time was due to my friends. At the same time I did find some positive things to say about Diamonds of ST. Matthews.
Diamonds is a decent size bar. They have a large number of pool tables. Don’t ask me how many, I never did count. The bar is large and the prices are not that bad. I had some Jameson on the rocks and paid $6.25 or $6.50 for it, which is not that bad. I then ordered a 23 ounce Guinness which was $5.75, a very good price. Don’t get me wrong, it was watered down when compared to the pour I get from the Irish Rover. Then again, most Louisville (and American bars) cannot pour a Guinness correctly.
After my first beer was down, I ordered “The Buffalo”, a Buffalo chicken sandwich which came with homemade potato chips. The sandwich was really good. I only wish the hot sauce had a little more kick to it. Other than that, the sandwich was very tasty. The homemade chips were awesome. They were BBQ and had a great flavor to them.
I did like how clean the bar was. They do an excellent job keeping that place clean. Even the men’s restroom had clean floors and clean looking sinks. Most bars, no matter how clean they are, have nasty restrooms. Diamonds does a excellent job keeping the entire building clean. When leaving the restroom I didn’t feel like I had caught an STD.
Service there was so, so. I know my friends and I are not regulars. I did not expect VIP treatment. The female bartender was very nice. No, I am not saying that because she was cute. She always smiled and called me “honey” when I ordered from her. The male bartender was not very good. He was not even nice to my female friends. Some of the other staff was not too friendly either.
Outside they have a nice deck and tons of sitting room. They have a small bar outside and had two guys playing live music. The bar was mix of different people. Near the bar, it seemed older men, mostly white hung around. Your “wanna be tough” guys with wife beaters hung around the pool tables. Outside was more of your college to preppy type of people. The only person who bothered us was an old guy who was trying to hit on my two female friends. What a loser!
Overall, I would give the bar a 7.5 out of 10. Not bad since I boycotted the bar for years, even when I lived within a mile from there. Would I go again? Not alone. No desire. Would I go with some friends? Yes I would. Decent prices and really good junk bar food.